Heat Fleet lists hundreds of local oil company deals, so you can get the best heating oil delivery prices in Shelter Island
NY
$3.69 /gal Cheapest heating oil price in Shelter Island
Customers Love Heat Fleet
109,185 searches in the last year on Heat Fleet
Save 23% or moreHeat Fleet's Shelter Island oil price is 75¢ less than the NY average
Order With Confidence5.0 rating on Google 
Buy Big + Save MoreVolume discounts on fuel oil kick in at 150 gallons 
Pay Later by PayPalPay for your heating oil order in 4 interest-free installments Benefits
Oil Companies
Oil Prices
Heating Oil
Oil Delivery
Benefits
Heating oil payment options that fit every Shelter Island family's budget
With three ways to pay, Heat Fleet makes paying for heating oil in Shelter Island both easier and more convenient.
Card
PCI Level 1 Security
E-Wallet
4 Interest-Free Payments | No Late Fees
100 gallons Heating Oil
$60.75
Today
$60.75
May 23
$60.75
Jun 6
$60.75
Jul 20
Heat Fleet is a proud member of Shelter Island's energy industry trade associations.
Enter your ZIP - that’s it!
Oil Companies
Oil Prices in Shelter Island, NY
Updated on July 4, 2025 at 05:00 PM
| Heating Oil Company | Oil Price Per Gallon | Cash Discount | Volume Discount |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tandy Oil Company | $3.69 | Yes | Yes |
| Marshall and Sons Fuel Oil | Call for price | No | No |
| Hamptons Quality | Call for price | No | No |
| Mcburnie Fuels | Call for price | No | No |
| Burts Reliable | Call for price | No | No |
| Calverton Fuel Oil | Call for price | No | No |
| Demarest Holding Corp | Call for price | No | No |
| East End Container Service | Call for price | No | No |
| Eastern Fuel Inc | Call for price | No | No |
| FuelCo Inc | Call for price | No | No |
| Grissom Fuel Oil Company | Call for price | No | No |
| Harding Fuel Inc | Call for price | No | No |
| Heras Fuel Oil Corp | Call for price | No | No |
| Indigo Fuel | Call for price | No | No |
| J W Piccozzi Fuel Oil Company | Call for price | No | No |
| Jarzombek Energy | Call for price | No | No |
| Mendenhall Fuel Inc | Call for price | No | No |
| Peconic Energy Corp | Call for price | No | No |
| Quogue Sinclair Fuel | Call for price | No | No |
| W F Mccoy Petroleum Products | Call for price | No | No |
| WC Esp Inc | Call for price | No | No |
| Z and S Fuel and Service | Call for price | No | No |
| Eckert Oil Service | Call for price | No | No |
| Houcks Fuel Oil Company | Call for price | No | No |
| Hurricane Fuel Oil | Call for price | No | No |
| Long Island Ice and Fuel Corp | Call for price | No | No |
| Mapes Fuel Oil | Call for price | No | No |
| NYC Fuel Service | Call for price | No | No |
| Twin Forks Fuel | Call for price | No | No |
Shelter Island Homeowner’s Guide to Selecting an Oil Company
For Shelter Island homeowners heating with oil, selecting which of the 29 heating oil companies that serve Shelter Island is an important decision.
Full Service Oil Companies: Homeowners willing to pay a premium for a “set-it-and-forget-it” heating system choose one of the 13 “full-service” oil companies that serve Shelter Island. Full service companies such as J W Piccozzi Inc Piccozzi's Fuel Oil Co or W C Esp Inc offer automatic fuel delivery and furnace repair under a single roof.
Discount Oil Companies: Also known by the names “COD Fuel Companies” or “Cash Heating Oil Companies”, these companies are for the budget-conscious Shelter Island homeowner. In return for better prices, you monitor the oil level in your tank and place an order when you run low on oil. Examples of cash heating oil companies that serve Shelter Island include East End Container Service Inc East End Fuel and Tandy Oil Company LLC.
Shelter Island Heating Oil Company Fast Facts
Heating Oil Companies Serving Shelter Island: 29 companies
Average Distance From Oil Company to Shelter Island: 18 miles
Average Number Of Shelter Island Homes Served Per Company: 28 homes
Average Gallons Delivered per Shelter Island Oil Company: 13,759 gallons per year
Shelter Island, NY Heating Oil Trends
Last year, Shelter Island homeowners purchased a total of 399,020 gallons of heating oil. Out of the 1008 towns in New York, Shelter Island ranks 315th for home heating oil consumption.
Country-wide, Shelter Island ranks 1818th out of 29,620 towns in America for heating oil consumption.
Short Term Trends
Shelter Island’s overall heating oil use varies from year to year, primarily depending on how cold each winter is. As the temperature outside gets colder, homes’ heating systems need to burn more and more oil to keep homes warm. Last winter in Shelter Island, the average outside temperature was 1.7° F colder than the prior winter's average outside temperature.
Shelter Island Average Winter Temperature
| Heating Season | Average Temperature |
|---|---|
| 2024 - 2025 | 39.6° F |
| 2023 - 2024 | 41.3° F |
Oil Prices
Cheapest Shelter Island, NY Oil Price Per Gallon
Grab the best oil prices for your family by searching by ZIP code on Heat Fleet.
| Quantity | Price | Updated At |
|---|---|---|
| 100 gallonsgals | $3.69 per gallon/gal | Jul 4, 2025, 5:00 PM |
| 150 gallonsgals | $3.59 per gallon/gal | Jul 4, 2025, 5:00 PM |
| 200 gallonsgals | $3.59 per gallon/gal | Jul 4, 2025, 5:00 PM |
| 250 gallonsgals | $3.59 per gallon/gal | Jul 4, 2025, 5:00 PM |
Shelter Island Heating Oil Price History
Updated on July 4, 2025 at 12:00 AM
| Date | Price |
|---|---|
| 07/04/2025 | $3.690 |
| 07/03/2025 | $3.690 |
| 07/02/2025 | $3.690 |
| 07/01/2025 | $3.690 |
| 06/30/2025 | $3.690 |
| 06/29/2025 | $3.690 |
| 06/28/2025 | $3.690 |
| 06/27/2025 | $3.690 |
| 06/26/2025 | $3.690 |
| 06/25/2025 | $3.690 |
| 06/24/2025 | $3.690 |
| 06/23/2025 | $3.690 |
| 06/22/2025 | $3.690 |
| 06/21/2025 | $3.690 |
| 06/20/2025 | $3.690 |
| 06/19/2025 | $3.690 |
| 06/18/2025 | $3.690 |
| 06/17/2025 | $3.690 |
| 06/16/2025 | $3.690 |
| 06/15/2025 | $3.490 |
| 06/14/2025 | $3.490 |
| 06/02/2025 | $3.290 |
| 06/01/2025 | $3.290 |
| 05/31/2025 | $3.290 |
| 05/30/2025 | $3.290 |
| 05/29/2025 | $3.290 |
| 05/28/2025 | $3.290 |
| 05/27/2025 | $3.290 |
| 05/26/2025 | $3.290 |
| 05/25/2025 | $3.290 |
Heating Oil
20 Seconds Can Save Shelter Island Families $1,000+ On Oil Bills Every Year
Propane vs. Natural Gas vs. Heating Oil: Shelter Island Home Heating Fuel Comparison
Homeowners have a variety of home heating fuels to choose from. Heating oil is the most popular choice in Shelter Island, used by 828 or 46.44% of homes. The 2nd most popular choice for Shelter Island homeowners is propane, used by 571 homes (32.02%). The remaining homes are heated with wood (310), natural gas (156), electricity (146).
Shelter Island Primary Home Heating Fuel Popularity by Number of Households
| Fuel | Shelter Island Households | % of Households |
|---|---|---|
| Heating Oil | 828 | 46.4% |
| Propane | 571 | 32.0% |
| Wood | 310 | 17.4% |
| Natural Gas | 156 | 8.8% |
| Electricity | 146 | 8.2% |
Heating oil (46.4%)
Propane (32.0%)
Wood (17.4%)
Natural gas (8.8%)
Electricity (8.2%)
#2 Heating Oil (Fuel Oil) Use in Shelter Island
Heating oil has become more popular in Shelter Island. In the 11 years since 2011, the number of heating oil homes rose from 590 to 828, a 40.34% lift.
Shelter Island Heating Oil Households (2011 - 2022)
| Year | Heating Oil Households |
|---|---|
| 2011 | 590 |
| 2012 | 553 |
| 2013 | 535 |
| 2014 | 549 |
| 2015 | 574 |
| 2016 | 596 |
| 2017 | 536 |
| 2018 | 539 |
| 2019 | 520 |
| 2020 | 580 |
| 2021 | 693 |
| 2022 | 828 |
Propane vs. Natural Gas use for home heating in Shelter Island
Between 2011 and today, the number of homes using propane as the primary space heating fuel rose from 53 to 571.
Between 2011 and today, the number of homes using natural gas as the primary space heating fuel rose from 20 to 156.
Electricity use for home heating in Shelter Island
Electric space heating systems are becoming more popular in Shelter Island. Since 2011, the number of homes heating with electricity rose from 98 to 146, a 48.98% increase.
Solar use for home heating in Shelter Island
Solar is the most environmentally friendly of all space heating fuels. With an “active” solar heating system, liquid is circulated between solar panels on a home’s roof and a heat energy storage tank in the basement.
Homeowners in Shelter Island have not yet adopted solar heating.
Why Shelter Island Homeowners Choose Heat Fleet?
Quality Oil
On-Time Delivery
No Contracts
Secure Ordering
Pay Later
4 interest free payments with
Oil Delivery
Shelter Island, NY Heating Oil Delivery Map
Grab the best oil prices for your family by searching by ZIP code on Heat Fleet.
Shelter Island, NY Heating Oil Delivery Overview
Approximately 828 households in Shelter Island, NY heat their homes with fuel oil. This makes oil delivery essential, especially when Shelter Island, NY temperatures drop as low as 42.5° F each winter.
46% of Shelter Island, NY Households Rely On Heating Oil Delivery Each Winter
| Shelter Island, NY Households | Shelter Island, NY Heating Oil Households |
|---|---|
| 1,783 | 828 |
29 Shelter Island, NY Oil Companies Go the Distance
With 399,019 gallons of heating oil delivered to Shelter Island, NY homeowners during the winter of 2024, the Shelter Island, NY community relies on its 29 oil companies to keep warm.
Oil delivery is a two step process: First, an oil truck picks up oil at the nearest bulk fuel terminal. In the case of Shelter Island, NY, two of the closest terminals are null in null and null in null. Then, the truck delivers the #2 heating oil to homes and businesses in Shelter Island, NY.
Shelter Island Heating Oil Prices FAQs
Is the price of heating oil in Shelter Island, NY rising or falling?
The price of heating oil in Shelter Island, NY has been falling over the last 7 days, with a total decrease of $0.00 per gallon.
What is the price of home heating oil today in Shelter Island, NY?
Today in Shelter Island, NY, the price of home heating oil is $3.69 per gallon, which amounts to $369.00 for a 100-gallon order (excluding any applicable taxes).
Is heating oil going up or down in Shelter Island, NY?
Heating oil prices have gone down in Shelter Island, NY by $0.00 per gallon over the past 7 days, which amounts to a $0.00 for a 100-gallon order.
How high will oil go in Shelter Island, NY?
There’s no limit to how high oil prices can go in Shelter Island, NY. Over the past year, Shelter Island, NY heating oil prices per gallon have risen as high as $5.66 for a 100-gallon order. This is $1.97 per gallon more than the current average price of $3.69, and $1.97 per gallon more than the lowest price currently available, which is $3.69. Home heating oil prices fluctuate daily based on several factors, including demand, local fuel inventories at terminals (such as CITGO), and the price of crude oil.
